Looking to attract more birds to your backyard without the mess, wasted seed and piles of discarded sunflower shells? Discover why sunflower hearts are one of the best choices for backyard bird feeding and why more bird enthusiasts are making the switch.
If you've ever stood in front of a bird seed display wondering which bag to take home, you're certainly not alone.
With so many different types of bird seed available, choosing the right one can be confusing. Black oil sunflower, striped sunflower, sunflower hearts, safflower, nyjer and a seemingly endless selection of mixed bird seed blends all promise to attract birds to your backyard.
But if there is one recommendation I would make to anyone looking to attract a wonderful variety of backyard birds, it would be to give sunflower hearts a try.
Why? Because sunflower hearts offer excellent nutritional value, are enjoyed by a wide variety of backyard birds and, perhaps best of all, they are the ultimate NO MESS, NO WASTE bird seed!
Let's take a closer look at why sunflower hearts are such a great choice and how they compare with traditional black oil sunflower seed.
1. What Are Sunflower Hearts?
Sunflower hearts are simply sunflower seeds with their outer shells removed, leaving behind the nutritious kernel that birds actually eat.
Think of them as sunflower seeds with all the unnecessary packaging taken off!
This small difference offers some pretty significant advantages.
NO MESS – No More Piles of Sunflower Shells!
Anyone who has been feeding birds for a while knows what happens underneath a traditional sunflower feeder. Empty shells accumulate on patios, decks, lawns and garden beds. Eventually, someone has to clean them up!
With sunflower hearts, there are no discarded sunflower shells. Birds consume the entire kernel, leaving considerably less mess underneath your feeders.
Imagine enjoying your backyard birds without having to rake up piles of sunflower shells every weekend!
This makes sunflower hearts particularly attractive for homeowners who have feeders over patios, decks, balconies or landscaped gardens.

NO WASTE – The Birds Get to Eat the Good Stuff!
When birds are offered some mixed bird seed products, they often pick through the mixture, selecting their preferred seeds and discarding others they don't particularly enjoy.
This can leave a surprising amount of unwanted seed scattered underneath your feeder.
With sunflower hearts, you are providing birds with the nutritious part of the seed right from the start.
There are no inedible sunflower shells to discard and virtually nothing goes to waste.
And remember, when purchasing traditional black oil sunflower seed, you are paying for the entire seed, including the outer shell that birds eventually throw away.
With sunflower hearts, virtually the entire product is edible.
Excellent Nutritional Value
Sunflower hearts contain valuable fats, oils and calories, making them an excellent food choice throughout the year.
They are particularly beneficial during the colder winter months when birds need additional energy to maintain their body temperature.
It's easy to understand why sunflower hearts have become such a favourite among experienced backyard bird enthusiasts.
2. What Birds Eat Sunflower Hearts?
One of the biggest advantages of sunflower hearts is the variety of birds they can attract.
They are particularly popular with:
- Northern Cardinals
- Black-capped Chickadees
- American Goldfinches
- House Finches
- White-breasted Nuthatches
- Rose-breasted Grosbeaks
- Dark-eyed Juncos
- Purple Finches
Many other seed-eating backyard birds.
If you're trying to attract more cardinals, chickadees and finches, sunflower hearts are an excellent starting point.
They are also particularly convenient because you don't need a different seed for every bird visiting your backyard.
Of course, not every bird eats seeds. Robins, hummingbirds and many other species have different dietary preferences. But for attracting a wide variety of common seed-eating birds, sunflower hearts are hard to beat.
3. What Is Black Oil Sunflower Seed?
Black oil sunflower seed is another excellent and popular choice for backyard bird feeding.
Unlike sunflower hearts, black oil sunflower seeds retain their outer shells. They are relatively small, have thin shells that are easy for many birds to crack open, and contain valuable oils and fats.
They are particularly popular with finches, sparrows, cardinals, chickadees, mourning doves and other common backyard birds.
So what's the downside?
The shells!
As birds eat the seeds, they discard the empty hulls. Some seeds may also be dropped or discarded, creating a buildup of debris underneath feeders.
For homeowners who have feeders over a deck, patio or landscaped garden, this can become a bit of a nuisance.

And remember, those discarded shells and spilled seeds can provide an additional food source for unwanted visitors.
It's also important to remember that when you purchase black oil sunflower seed, part of the weight you are paying for is the inedible outer shell.
In other words, the birds aren't eating everything in the bag.
4. Less Mess and Less Waste Can Mean Less Attraction for Unwanted Rodents
Here's another benefit of sunflower hearts that homeowners might not immediately consider.
Bird feeders can sometimes attract unwanted visitors, particularly mice and rats.
Why? Because discarded sunflower shells, spilled seed and uneaten food underneath feeders can provide an easy meal for rodents.
Traditional sunflower seeds leave behind piles of empty hulls, while inexpensive mixed bird seed can result in considerable amounts of unwanted seed being scattered around the feeding area.
By switching to sunflower hearts, you eliminate the discarded sunflower shells and reduce the amount of food debris accumulating beneath your feeders.
Less mess and less wasted food mean fewer opportunities to attract unwanted rodents.
Of course, sunflower hearts aren't rodent-proof. Birds can still drop edible kernels, so it's important to avoid overfilling feeders, use appropriate feeder trays, select properly designed tube feeders with a “reach-in” port and regularly clean up any spilled food.
If you've noticed birdseed sprouting beneath your feeder, read our Why Is Birdseed Sprouting Under My Feeder, and How Do I Stop It? guide for practical ways to prevent unwanted seedlings, reduce spilled seed, and choose seed-catching accessories to keep your lawn or garden tidy.
It's another excellent reason to make sunflower hearts your preferred backyard bird seed!
5. Why We Recommend Sunflower Hearts at Urban Nature Store
At Urban Nature Store, we have been helping Canadians enjoy backyard birds for more than 20 years.
Over that time, we've heard plenty of customer questions about bird seed, feeders and attracting more birds.
Our recommendation is straightforward:
If you are looking for one versatile bird seed to offer in your backyard, sunflower hearts should be at the top of your list.
Our popular Sunflower Hearts – No Mess, No Waste Birdseed are available in several bag sizes to suit different feeding needs.
Whether you have one feeder outside your kitchen window or several feeding stations around your property, you can choose the quantity that works best for you.
Here are just a few reasons customers love them:
- Birds love them: Nutritious sunflower kernels enjoyed by a wide variety of seed-eating birds.
- No mess: No piles of discarded sunflower shells underneath your feeders.
- No waste: Virtually the entire product is edible.
- Less rodent attraction: Less discarded food and shell debris accumulating beneath feeders.
- Excellent nutrition: A valuable source of fats, oils and calories.
- Convenience: Particularly attractive for patios, decks, balconies and smaller gardens.
We also offer finely chopped sunflower hearts, which are particularly useful for certain finch feeders designed for smaller feeding ports.
Our advice? Make sunflower hearts the foundation of your backyard bird feeding station. You can always introduce other specialty seeds to attract particular species.
6. Are There Times When Black Oil Sunflower Seed Makes Sense?
Absolutely!
We don't want to suggest that black oil sunflower seed is a poor choice. Quite the opposite.
It remains an excellent, nutritious bird food and is particularly useful for people who want to attract a broad selection of common backyard birds at an economical initial purchase price.
However, if you prefer less mess, less waste and fewer discarded shells accumulating beneath your feeders, sunflower hearts are our first choice.
When you consider the convenience, nutritional value and reduced cleanup, sunflower hearts offer a very attractive alternative.
7. What Is the Best Way to Feed Sunflower Hearts?
One of the great things about sunflower hearts is their versatility.
They can be offered in several different types of bird feeders, including:
Tube Feeders: An excellent choice for attracting chickadees, finches and nuthatches.
For sunflower hearts, consider Brome Bird Care's Tube Solution 150 Bird Feeder or Tube Solution 200 Bird Feeder. Both offer multiple feeding ports, bird-friendly perches and easy-to-clean components.

Hopper Feeders: These provide a larger feeding area and are particularly attractive to cardinals and other larger songbirds.
Platform Feeders: An excellent option for birds that prefer an open feeding area and for attracting a variety of species.
A little advice: keep your feeders clean, ensure the seed stays dry and avoid putting out more food than your birds can consume before it becomes damp or spoiled.
If you want to further discourage rodents, position feeders away from buildings where practical, avoid overfilling them and regularly clean up any spilled food.
8. Ready to Make the Switch?
If you've been feeding traditional mixed bird seed or black oil sunflower for years, why not give sunflower hearts a try?
You might be surprised by the variety of birds that visit your backyard.
And you'll certainly appreciate having fewer discarded shells, less mess on your patio and less food debris accumulating underneath your feeders.
At Urban Nature Store, we believe feeding wild birds should be enjoyable for both the birds and the people who care about them.
Our advice is simple:
FEED YOUR BIRDS WHAT THEY LOVE. ENJOY THE NO MESS. APPRECIATE THE NO WASTE!
Explore our selection of sunflower hearts and other quality bird seed at UrbanNatureStore.ca.
Your backyard birds will thank you!
Urban Nature Store
Your Local Birding and Nature Experts
Nature Inspired Gifts for Every Generation.
Related Reading
For more information on choosing birdseed and keeping your feeding area clean, explore our Sunflower Hearts vs. Black Oil Sunflower Seeds: Which Is Better for Backyard Birds? and What Is the Best No-Mess Birdseed for a Backyard, Deck or Patio? guides.


